Psychodynamic theories, including Freud's, have faced criticism on several counts. Which of the following is NOT a criticism of these theories?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (4) → Overemphasis on situational factors
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1): Lack of scientific verification. A criticism of psychodynamic theories. | The theories rest largely on case studies and lack a rigorous scientific basis. Their concepts are not properly defined, so they are hard to check by scientific methods. |
| Option (2): Use of atypical individuals as samples. A criticism of psychodynamic theories. | The theories draw small and atypical individuals as samples and then make generalisations about all people from them. |
| Option (3): Male-centric perspective. A criticism of psychodynamic theories. | Freud took males as the prototype of all human personality development. Female experiences and perspectives were overlooked. |
| Option (4): Overemphasis on situational factors. Not a criticism of psychodynamic theories. | These theories explain behaviour through unconscious inner conflicts rooted in early childhood. The criticisms made of them concern their method, samples, concepts and male focus. |
NCERT (2026-27): “Erik Erikson : Search for Identity … “(1) The theories are largely based on case studies; they lack a rigorous scientific basis.” “(2) They use small and atypical individuals as samples for advancing generalisations.” “(3) The concepts are not properly defined, and it is difficult to submit them to scientific testing.” “(4) Freud has used males as the prototype of all human personality development. He overlooked female experiences and perspectives.” |