A historian reads a story from a collection of tales written in Pali around the middle of the first millennium CE. In it, a king goes about in disguise among his subjects - elderly women and men, cultivators, herders, village boys and even animals - to learn what they think of him. Each of them curses him for their miseries. They complain that robbers attack them at night and that the king's officials come upon them during the day. In the end, the people leave their village and go to live in the forest.
Which of the following best states what historians infer from such a story about kings and their rural subjects?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → Their relations were strained, as kings demanded high taxes that peasants found oppressive
Option (1) Their relations were strained, as kings recruited village youths into the royal army — Incorrect. The people in the story complain of robbers and of the king's officials. Nothing in it points to youths being taken into an army, so this cause does not fit.
Option (2) Their relations were strained, as kings demanded high taxes that peasants found oppressive — Correct. The story is the Gandatindu Jataka, where the daytime attackers are tax collectors. From it historians infer that kings often filled their treasuries by demanding high taxes, which peasants found oppressive.
Option (3) Their relations were strained, as kings handed villages to new lords through land grants — Incorrect. Land grants to new lords are a real feature of the period, recorded in inscriptions. But the story has no village handed over to anyone, so it cannot support this inference.
Option (4) Their relations were strained, as kings forced peasants to labour on royal buildings — Incorrect. The villagers do not complain of forced work on royal buildings. Their miseries come from night robbers and daytime officials, so this cause does not fit.
NCERT (2026-27): “5.1 Popular perceptions of kings “As this story indicates, the relationship between a king and his subjects, especially the rural population, could often be strained – kings frequently tried to fill their coffers by demanding high taxes, and peasants particularly found such demands oppressive. …” |