Which of the following was NOT one of the reasons why zamindars failed to pay the revenue demand in the early decades after the Permanent Settlement?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → The demand was imposed when agricultural prices were rising.
Option (1) The initial revenue demands were pegged very high. — A reason for the default. The Company pegged the demand high at the start. It feared it could never claim a share of later gains once the demand was fixed for all time.
Option (2) The revenue was invariable, regardless of the harvest. — A reason for the default. The revenue stayed the same whatever the harvest and had to be paid on time. A bad year gave the zamindar no relief.
Option (3) The demand was imposed when agricultural prices were rising. — Not a reason for the default. The feature is reversed. The high demand came in the 1790s, when prices of farm produce were depressed, not rising. Low prices made it hard for ryots to pay rent to the zamindar.
Option (4) The zamindar's power to collect rent was initially limited. — A reason for the default. The Permanent Settlement at first limited the zamindar's power to collect rent from the ryot and run his zamindari. Without rent he could not pay the Company.
NCERT (2026-27): “1.3 Why zamindars defaulted on payments … “Second: this high demand was imposed in the 1790s, a time when the prices of agricultural produce were depressed, making it difficult for the ryots to pay their dues to the zamindar. If the zamindar could not collect the rent, how could he pay the Company? Third: the revenue was invariable, regardless of the harvest, and had to be paid punctually. In fact, according to the Sunset Law, if payment did not come in by sunset of the specified date, the zamindari was liable to be auctioned. Fourth: the Permanent Settlement initially limited the power of the zamindar to collect rent from the ryot and manage his zamindari. …” |