Read the following case and answer the question.
Due to heavy demand in the market, the Automobile Company XYZ Ltd. is facing shortage of manpower. Currently it has 5000 employees and need 500 more due to heavy demand. The manufacturing unit of company majority requires mechanical engineers, mechanic and designers. In a recent meeting various suggestions were obtained from HR manager, finance manager and production manager to the company. HR manager says Advertisement is a good method of recruitment whereas production manager is of the opinion to do campus recruitment. Finance manager refuses both offers as both are costly source of recruitment. According to him recommendation of employees is the best source.
Finance Manager refuses suggestions given by HR Manager and Production Manager on the ground of costly affair.
Which of the following can be disadvantage of External source of recruitment like advertisement and campus recruitment ?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Time consuming
Option (1) Time consuming — Correct. External sources of recruitment mean finding people from outside the company. This is a lengthy process: the company has to give notice of the vacancies and then wait for the applications. It is also costly, as the Finance Manager says in the case.
Option (2) Large number of potential Candidates — Incorrect. This is a merit, not a drawback. When vacancies are advertised widely, a large number of people apply, so the company gets a wider choice.
Option (3) Dissatisfaction among existing staff would not be there — Incorrect. This is the opposite of the fact. External recruitment may cause dissatisfaction among the present employees, because they feel their chances of promotion are reduced. And even if it were true, it would be a benefit, not a disadvantage.
Option (4) Will bring fresh talent — Incorrect. This is also a merit. External recruitment brings new blood into the organisation.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “(ii) Wider Choice: When vacancies are advertised widely, a large number of applicants from outside the organisation apply. The management has a wider choice while selecting the people for employment.” “(iii) Fresh Talent: The present employees may be insufficient or they may not fulfill the specifications of the jobs to be filled. External recruitment provide wider choice and brings new blood in the organisation. However, it is expensive and time-consuming.” “Limitations of External Sources 1. Dissatisfaction among existing staff: External recruitment may lead to dissatisfaction and frustration among existing employees. They may feel that their chances of promotion are reduced.” “2. Lengthy process: Recruitment from external sources takes a long time. The business has to notify the vacancies and wait for applications to initiate the selection process.” “3. Costly process: It is very costly to recruit staff from external sources. A lot of money has to be spent on advertisement and processing of applications.” |