Practicing Success

Target Exam

CUET

Subject

History

Chapter

Modern India: Framing the Constitution

Question:

Match the following options in List 1 correctly with those in List 2:

List 1

List 2

(a) Begum Aizaas Rasul

(i)  Believed separate electorates will be suicidal to the minorities.

(b) Sardar Patel

(ii) Felt that separate electorates were self-destructive.

(c) Govind Ballabh Pant

(iii) Made a powerful plea for continuing separate electorates.

(d) B. Pocker Bahadur

(iv) Felt separate electorates were a poison that has entered the body politic of our country.

 

Options:

(a)- ii, (b)- iv, (c)- iii, (d) i

(a)- iv, (b)- ii, (c)- i, (d) iii

(a)- ii, (b)- i, (c)- iv, (d) iii

(a)- ii, (b)- iv, (c)- i, (d) iii

Correct Answer:

(a)- ii, (b)- iv, (c)- i, (d) iii

Explanation:

The correct answer is Option 4 - (a)- ii, (b)- iv, (c)- i, (d) iii

Correct Match:

List 1

List 2

(a) Begum Aizaas Rasul

(ii) Felt that separate electorates were self-destructive.

(b) Sardar Patel

(iv) Felt separate electorates were a poison that has entered the body politic of our country.

(c) Govind Ballabh Pant

(i)  Believed separate electorates will be suicidal to the minorities.

(d) B. Pocker Bahadur

(iii) Made a powerful plea for continuing separate electorates.

Explanation:

Different views on separate electorates:
Not all Muslims supported the demand for separate electorates. Begum Aizaas Rasul, for instance, felt that separate electorates were self- destructive since they isolated the minorities from the majority. By 1949, most Muslim members of the Constituent Assembly were agreed that separate electorates wer e against the interests of the minorities. Instead Muslims needed to take an active part in the democratic process to ensure that they had a decisive voice in the political system.

Partition had made nationalists fervently opposed to the idea of separate electorates. They were haunted by the fear of continued civil war, riots and violence. Separate electorates was a “poison that has entered the body politic of our country”, declared Sardar Patel. It was a demand that had turned one community against another, divided the nation, caused bloodshed, and led to the tragic partition of the country.

During the debate on 27 August 1947, Govind Ballabh Pant said: I believe separate electorates will be suicidal to the minorities and will do them tremendous harm. If they are isolated for ever, they can never convert themselves into a majority and the feeling of frustration will cripple them even from the very beginning.

On 27 August 1947, B. Pocker Bahadur from Madras made a powerful plea for continuing separate electorates. Minorities exist in all lands, argued Bahadur; they could not be wished away, they could not be “erased out of existence”. The need was to create a political framework in which minorities could live in harmony with others, and the differences between communities could be minimised. This was possible only if minorites were well represented within the political system, their voices heard and their views taken into account. Only separate electorates would ensure that Muslims had a meaningful voice in the governance of the country. The needs of Muslims, Bahadur felt, could not be properly understood by non-Muslims; nor could a true representative of Muslims be chosen by people who did not belong to that community.