A machine bought for Rs. 3,20,000 is to be replaced after 5 years. Its scrap will then sell for Rs. 20,000, and a new machine will cost Rs. 3,80,000. To meet the difference, the owner deposits an equal amount at the beginning of every year in a sinking fund earning 10% per annum compounded annually. Each deposit is (Given \((1.1)^5 = 1.61051\))
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Rs. 53,606.45
The fund must provide the replacement cost minus the scrap value:
\(A = 380000 - 20000 = 360000\)
The deposits are made at the beginning of each year, so each one earns interest for one more year than in an ordinary annuity. The amount of an annuity due is
\( \displaystyle A = R\,(1+i)\left[\frac{(1+i)^n - 1}{i}\right] \)
With i = 0.1 and n = 5:
\( \displaystyle (1.1) \times \frac{1.61051 - 1}{0.1} = 1.1 \times 6.1051 = 6.71561 \)
\( \displaystyle R = \frac{360000}{6.71561} \)
\(\approx 53606.45\)
Why the other options are incorrect
Option (1) Rs. 72,000 — Incorrect. This is 360000 ÷ 5, which ignores the interest earned by the fund.
Option (2) Rs. 58,967.09 — Incorrect. This is 360000 ÷ 6.1051, the deposit if it were made at the end of each year.
Option (3) Rs. 56,584.58 — Incorrect. This is 380000 ÷ 6.71561, which builds up the full cost of the new machine and forgets the scrap money.