Identify the incorrect statement(s) from the following in the context of an electric current flowing through a conductor.
(A) The electrons suffer collisions with heavy fixed ions in the conductor
(B) The resistance of the given conductor depends on its temperature
(C) Resistance and resistivity both depend on the dimensions of the conductor
(D) When a potential difference V is applied across the conductor then V = IR
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → (C) only
(A) The electrons suffer collisions with heavy fixed ions in the conductor — Correct. The free electrons drift through a lattice of positive ions and keep colliding with the ions; these collisions are the origin of resistance.
(B) The resistance of the given conductor depends on its temperature — Correct. Heating makes the ions vibrate more and shortens the relaxation time, so the resistance of a metal rises with temperature.
(C) Resistance and resistivity both depend on the dimensions of the conductor — Incorrect. Resistance depends on the dimensions, \( R = \rho l/A \), but resistivity is a property of the material (at a given temperature) and does not depend on the length or the area.
(D) When a potential difference V is applied across the conductor then V = IR — Correct. This is Ohm's law: the current is proportional to the applied potential difference, with \( R \) the resistance.
NCERT (2026-27):
Ohm’s Law – “… Then Ohm’s law states that
\( \displaystyle V \propto I \quad \text{or,} \quad V = R\,I \qquad (3.3) \)
where the constant of proportionality R is called the resistance of the conductor. … The resistance R not only depends on the material of the conductor but also on the dimensions of the conductor.”
Ohm’s Law – “… Combining Eqs. (3.5) and (3.7), we have
\( \displaystyle R \propto \frac{l}{A} \qquad (3.8) \)
and hence for a given conductor
\( \displaystyle R = \rho \frac{l}{A} \qquad (3.9) \)
where the constant of proportionality \( \rho \) depends on the material of the conductor but not on its dimensions. \( \rho \) is called resistivity.”