Statement I: The ionisation enthalpy of Mn+ is higher than that of Cr+.
Statement II: The third ionisation enthalpy of iron is lower than that of manganese.
In the light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → Only Statement II is correct.
Exchange energy stabilises a set of electrons with parallel spins in degenerate orbitals, and it is largest for the half-filled d5 set. Removing an electron from a stable d5 set costs more energy, while removing one from d6 causes no loss of exchange energy and is easier.
Statement I: The ionisation enthalpy of Mn+ is higher than that of Cr+. — False. Cr+ is d5, so its next electron must come out of the stable half-filled set. Mn+ is 3d54s1 and loses the 4s electron, leaving the d5 set intact. So the ionisation enthalpy of Mn+ is lower than that of Cr+.
Statement II: The third ionisation enthalpy of iron is lower than that of manganese. — True. The third ionisation removes an electron from M2+. Fe2+ is d6 and becomes the stable d5 Fe3+; Mn2+ is d5 and would have to lose that stable arrangement. So Fe2+ is ionised more easily.
NCERT (2026-27 edition):
4.3.3 Ionisation Enthalpies – “…Exchange energy is responsible for the stabilisation of energy state.” … “There is no loss of exchange energy at d6 configuration. Mn+ has 3d54s1 configuration and configuration of Cr+ is d5, therefore, ionisation enthalpy of Mn+ is lower than Cr+. In the same way, Fe2+ has d6 configuration and Mn2+ has 3d5 configuration. Hence, ionisation enthalpy of Fe2+ is lower than the Mn2+. In other words, we can say that the third ionisation enthalpy of Fe is lower than that of Mn.”