Select the option that expresses the given sentence in direct speech.
The lifeguard forbade the children to swim beyond the red buoys.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → The lifeguard said to the children, “Don’t swim beyond the red buoys.”
Changing a negative order from indirect back into direct speech:
| Change | Indirect | Direct | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting verb | forbade the children | said to the children | Forbade means told someone not to do something. Going back, it becomes “said to” before the spoken words. |
| To + verb | to swim | “Don’t swim ...” | The spoken words are a negative order, so they begin with “Don’t” + verb. “To” is dropped. Buoys are floating markers in the water. |
| Full sentence | The lifeguard forbade the children to swim beyond the red buoys. | The lifeguard said to the children, “Don’t swim beyond the red buoys.” |
“Told ... not to” goes back to “Don’t” in the same way. Example: Mummy told Tia not to touch the hot iron. → “Don’t touch the hot iron,” Mummy said to Tia.
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 2: The lifeguard said to the children, “Don’t to swim beyond the red buoys.” — Incorrect. “To” is kept inside the quotation marks. An order begins with the verb itself: “Don’t swim”.
Option 3: The lifeguard said to the children, “Swim beyond the red buoys.” — Incorrect. “Not” is dropped, so the order tells the children to swim beyond the buoys. “Forbade” means the lifeguard told them not to.
Option 4: The lifeguard said to the children, “You did not swim beyond the red buoys.” — Incorrect. “You did not swim” is a statement about the past. “Forbade” reports an order, so the spoken words must be an order.