An epigraphist finds that several letters of a rock edict are so faintly engraved that two scholars propose different readings of one line. Which problem with inscriptional evidence does this show?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → A technical limitation that makes reconstructions uncertain
Option (1) A technical limitation that makes reconstructions uncertain — Correct. Faint letters are a technical limitation of inscriptions. When letters are very faintly engraved, scholars cannot be sure of the reading, so the reconstruction stays uncertain.
Option (2) The loss of many inscriptions to the ravages of time — Incorrect. Loss to the ravages of time means many inscriptions did not survive at all. Here the edict has survived; the trouble is reading its faint letters.
Option (3) The fact that not all inscriptions have been published — Incorrect. Many inscriptions found are not yet deciphered, published and translated. This edict is being read and debated, so publication is not the issue.
Option (4) The likelihood that most passers-by were not literate — Incorrect. Low literacy concerns whether ordinary people could read the edicts in their own time. Two modern scholars reading one faint line differently is a problem of the letters themselves.
NCERT (2026-27): “8. The Limitations of Inscriptional Evidence “Although several thousand inscriptions have been discovered, not all have been deciphered, published and translated. Besides, many more inscriptions must have existed, which have not survived the ravages of time. …” |