Passage 1: Detrimental debt
On the basis of this passage, answer the questions from Q. No. 6 to Q. No. 10.
Even successful businesses have debt, but how much is too much? Learning how to manage debt is what can put you ahead. Taking on the right amount of debt can mean the difference between a business struggling to survive and one that can respond nimbly to changing economic or market conditions. A number of circumstances may justify acquiring debt. As a general rule, borrowing makes the most sense when you need to bolster cash flow or finance growth or expansion. But while debt can provide the leverage you need to grow, too much debt can strangle your business. So the question is: How much debt is too much?
A business that doesn't grow dies. You've got to grow, but you've got to grow within the financial constraints of your business. What is the ideal capital structure a business needs in its industry to remain viable? The higher the volatility (in your industry), the less debt you should have. The smaller the volatility, the more debt you can afford. Consider the capital structure of a growing company, NextGen Ltd.
Total Funds used Rs. 30 Lakh
Interest rate is 10% p.a.
Tax rate 30%
EBIT Rs. 4 Lakh
Nextgen Ltd. has an option to raise different amounts of debt:
Situation I : No Debt
Situation II : Rs. 10 Lakh Debt
Situation III : Rs. 20 Lakh Debt
Identify the correct statement.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Situation III attracts more financial risk than Situation II
Option (1) Situation III attracts more financial risk than Situation II — Correct. Financial risk is the chance that a firm cannot make its fixed payments, such as interest and repayment of loans. More debt means more fixed interest, so more debt means more financial risk. Situation III has double the debt of Situation II (Rs. 20 lakh against Rs. 10 lakh), so its interest is higher (Rs. 2 lakh against Rs. 1 lakh at 10%) and it has more financial risk.
Option (2) Situation II attracts more financial risk than Situation III — Incorrect. Situation II has less debt than Situation III, so its risk is lower.
Option (3) Situation I attracts more financial risk than Situation III — Incorrect. Situation I has no debt and no interest to pay. It has the lowest financial risk.
Option (4) Situation I attracts more financial risk than Situation II — Incorrect. For the same reason, Situation I has less risk than Situation II.
Note: The passage is based on the NCERT box ‘Cutting Back on Debt’ and the EBIT-EPS example in the chapter Financial Management; NTA has changed the company name and added some lines. NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “Capital Structure … Debt is cheaper but is more risky for a business because the payment of interest and the return of principal is obligatory for the business. Any default in meeting these commitments may force the business to go into liquidation. There is no such compulsion in case of equity, which is therefore, considered riskless for the business. Higher use of debt increases the fixed financial charges of a business. As a result, increased use of debt increases the financial risk of a company.” “Financial risk is the chance that a firm would fail to meet its payment obligations.” “EBIT-EPS Analysis … Three situations are considered. There is no debt in situation-I i.e. (unlevered business). Debt of Rs. 10 lakh and 20 lakh are assumed in situations-II and III, respectively. All debt is at 10% p.a.” |