Read the following case study and answer the following question.
Ms. C bought an electric Iron from the market and paid money through cash to the vendor. Mr. X. But she forgets to collect the bill for the deal as a written evidence. The Iron was a ISI certified product. Once, she was using the Iron, she realised that it is not working properly. Then she immediately contacted the Vendor Mr. X and asked him to remove the defect in the product or replace it with a new one. The vendor did not listen to her and refused to accept that this product is sold by him to her. She discussed the matter with her father and he advised her to seek legal help in this case and finally she decided to file a case against the vendor in the consumer court. But while filing the case she got stuck in between due to non-availability of material evidences to produce before the court such as cash memo or bill of the transaction.
If Ms. C gets a chance to lodge a Complaint in court so which is right place to file a case first for getting the relief ?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → District Commission/District Forum
Option (1) National Commission — Incorrect. The National Commission hears cases where the value is above two crore rupees. An electric iron costs far less.
Option (2) District Commission/District Forum — Correct. An electric iron costs only a few thousand rupees. The District Commission hears complaints where the value does not exceed fifty lakh rupees. So the right place to file the case first is the district level. It is also called the ‘District Forum’.
Option (3) State Commission — Incorrect. The State Commission hears cases above fifty lakh rupees and up to two crore rupees. It also hears appeals against orders of the District Commission.
Option (4) Supreme Court — Incorrect. The Supreme Court is not one of the three levels set up under the Act. A case reaches it only as an appeal against an order of the National Commission.
Note: The money limits of the three Commissions have changed over the years, so each NCERT edition gives different limits. The table below compares them.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “Redressal Agencies Under The Consumer Protection Act For the redressal of consumer grievances, the Consumer Protection Act 2019 provides for setting up of a three-tier enforcement machinery at the District, State, and the National levels.” “District Commission: District commission has a jurisdiction to entertain complaints where value of goods or services paid as consideration does not exceed fifty lakh rupees. …” “State Commission: It is established by the respective state government and ordinarily function at the state capital. State Commission has a jurisdiction to entertain complaints where value of goods and services paid as consideration that exceeds rupees fifty lakh but does not exceed two crore. …” “National Commission: The National Commission has territorial jurisdiction over the whole country. National Commission has a jurisdiction to entertain complaints where value of goods or services paid as consideration exceeds two crores of rupees. If any of the parties are not satisfied by the order of National Commission can appeal against such order to the Supreme Court of India within a period of thirty days of such order.” “Redressal Agencies under the Consumer Protection Act: The Consumer Protection Act provides for setting up of a three-tier enforcement machinery at the District, State, and the National levels. They are referred to as the ‘District Forum’, ‘State Commission’, and the ‘National Commission’. …” |