Read the following passage and answer the question.
Kulkarni Kitchens
Rohan Kulkarni runs Kulkarni Kitchens, a chain of four takeaway kitchens in Pune. In every kitchen, one cook only kneads the dough, one only runs the tandoor and one only packs the orders. Each of them has been trained for that one task.
The head of each kitchen chooses the weekly specials and hires part-time helpers for the festival rush. The prices on the menu and the opening of any new kitchen, however, are decided by Rohan, who keeps the final say.
The appointment letter of every cook promises one day off each week and lists a fine for coming late to a shift. Last month the kitchens were very busy, but Rohan still gave every cook the weekly day off, and the cooks kept to their shift timings.
Rohan has told the cooks that anyone with a problem must tell the shift supervisor, who takes it to the head of the kitchen, who then takes it to Rohan.
When weekend duty is allotted, Rohan lets the cooks from his home town take their weekends off, while the other cooks have to work every weekend.
Rohan goes against a principle of Fayol in the way he allots weekend duty. Which of the following would go against the same principle?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → A manager allots the late shifts mostly to the cooks who follow one religion.
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) A manager allots each new cook to a different kitchen every month, before she can show results. Incorrect. | Moving a new cook to another kitchen every month denies her a minimum fixed tenure and time to show results, so it goes against stability of personnel, not equity. |
| Option (2) A manager has two supervisors allot the same cook’s shifts, and their orders often clash. Incorrect. | Two supervisors giving clashing orders means orders from two superiors, so this goes against unity of command, not equity. |
| Option (3) A manager allots the late shifts mostly to the cooks who follow one religion. Correct. | Giving late shifts by religion is discrimination on account of religion, which equity forbids, just as favouring cooks from one home town is unfair; so this goes against the same principle. |
| Option (4) A manager allots shifts with no fixed roster, so no cook knows her place or time of work. Incorrect. | Having no fixed roster leaves no cook a set place or time of work; this is a lack of order, not unfair treatment of some cooks, so it does not go against equity. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (3) (xi) Equity: “Good sense and experience are needed to ensure fairness to all employees, who should be treated as fairly as possible” “There should be no discrimination against anyone on account of gender, religion, language, caste, belief or nationality etc.” Wrong options (1) and (2) (xii) Stability of Personnel: “But once selected they should be kept at their post/ position for a minimum fixed tenure.” “They should be given reasonable time to show results.” (iv) Unity of Command: “If an employee gets orders from two superiors at the same time the principle of unity of command is violated.” |