A researcher plans two studies of family life in early India. The first is on a ruling lineage, using the Mahabharata, the epic whose central story concerns two groups of cousins of one ruling family who fought over land and power. The second is on the households of farmers, potters and labourers living in the same janapada. Before starting, she must decide which sources each study will need and how much time each will take.
Which expectation about her two studies is in line with how historians reconstruct families of early societies?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → The first will be easier, as ordinary people's family ties are far harder to reconstruct
Option (1) Both will be about equally easy, as normative Sanskrit texts cover farmers' families as well as kings' — Incorrect. Normative Sanskrit texts lay down rules of ideal behaviour, mostly for and about elite groups. They say little about the families of farmers and potters, so the second study will be harder.
Option (2) The second will be easier, as land-grant inscriptions describe ordinary households in detail — Incorrect. Land-grant inscriptions do not describe ordinary households in detail. For early societies, the family ties of ordinary people are in fact the harder ones to trace, so the second study will not be easier.
Option (3) The first will be easier, as ordinary people's family ties are far harder to reconstruct — Correct. Historians can find information about elite families fairly easily, but the family ties of ordinary people are far more difficult to reconstruct. A ruling lineage like the Kurus of the Mahabharata is well recorded, so the first study will be easier.
Option (4) Both will be about equally hard, as early texts seldom say much about family relationships — Incorrect. Early texts do say a good deal about elite families and kinship; the Mahabharata itself is a story about a family feud. So the two studies are not equally hard.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.1 Finding out about families … |