Which of the following statements is incorrect?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Two sucrose solutions of the same molality prepared in different solvents have the same depression in freezing point
For a dilute solution the depression of freezing point is \( \Delta T_f=K_f\,m \). The molality m is the same for both sucrose solutions, but Kf depends on the solvent (for example, 1.86 K kg mol−1 for water and 5.12 K kg mol−1 for benzene). So the two depressions are different.
Option (1) Two sucrose solutions of the same molality prepared in different solvents have the same depression in freezing point — An incorrect statement. Equal molality gives equal ΔTf only in the same solvent; a different solvent has a different Kf.
Option (2) The osmotic pressure (π) of a dilute solution is given by π = CRT, where C is the molarity of the solution — A correct statement. Osmotic pressure is proportional to the molar concentration C at temperature T, with R the gas constant.
Option (3) For a solution of volatile liquids, the partial vapour pressure of each component is directly proportional to its mole fraction in the solution — A correct statement. This is Raoult’s law, p1 = p10x1.
Option (4) The order of osmotic pressure of 0.01 M aqueous solutions is BaCl2 > KCl > CH3COOH > sucrose — A correct statement.
Osmotic pressure depends on the number of solute particles.
\( \ce{BaCl2} \) gives 3 ions (i = 3), KCl gives 2 (i = 2), acetic acid, a weak electrolyte, dissociates only slightly (i a little above 1), and sucrose does not dissociate (i = 1).
NCERT (2026-27 edition):
1.6.3 Depression of Freezing Point – “Similar to elevation of boiling point, depression of freezing point (ΔTf) for dilute solution (ideal solution) is directly proportional to molality, m of the solution. Thus,
\( \displaystyle \Delta T_f=K_f\,m \qquad (1.34) \)
The proportionality constant, Kf, which depends on the nature of the solvent is known as Freezing Point Depression Constant or Molal Depression Constant or Cryoscopic Constant.”