Anand consumes lesser units of good X when its price falls but more units of X when his income rises. Which of the following statements is true about good X.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Good X is both inferior and Giffen good for Anand.
Note: The given answer is as per the official NTA Answer Key. However, there seems to be a mistake in the question. A Giffen good is always an inferior good. So, at the same level of income, Anand cannot buy less X when its price falls and also buy more X when his income rises. No option fits both facts. The question would be correct if Anand bought fewer units of X when his income rises, as explained below.
A fall in price has two effects: X becomes cheaper than other goods, so the consumer buys more of it (substitution effect), and his money also buys more, as if income rose (income effect).
For a normal good, both effects raise demand. The question’s other fact, buying more X when income rises, would make X a normal good.
Option (1) Good X is an inferior good for Anand but not a Giffen good. — Incorrect. Then the substitution effect is stronger, and Anand would buy more X when its price falls.
Option (2) Good X is a Giffen good for Anand but not inferior. — Incorrect. Every Giffen good is inferior.
Option (3) Good X is normal good for Anand. — Incorrect. It fits the income fact, but demand for a normal good rises when its price falls.
Option (4) Good X is both inferior and Giffen good for Anand. — The answer given by NTA, but it seems to be incorrect. Anand buys less X when its price falls. This happens with a Giffen good. For such a good, the income effect works against the substitution effect and is stronger than it. So this option fits the price fact. But every Giffen good is an inferior good, and people buy less of an inferior good when their income rises. Anand buys more X when his income rises. So X cannot be an inferior good, and this option does not fit the income fact.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.4.3 Normal and Inferior Goods … The quantity of a good that the consumer demands can increase or decrease with the rise in income depending on the nature of the good. For most goods, the quantity that a consumer chooses, increases as the consumer’s income increases and decreases as the consumer’s income decreases. Such goods are called normal goods. … However, there are some goods the demands for which move in the opposite direction of the income of the consumer. Such goods are called inferior goods.… A rise in the purchasing power (income) of the consumer can sometimes induce the consumer to reduce the consumption of a good. In such a case, the substitution effect and the income effect will work in opposite directions. The demand for such a good can be inversely or positively related to its price depending on the relative strengths of these two opposing effects. If the substitution effect is stronger than the income effect, the demand for the good and the price of the good would still be inversely related. However, if the income effect is stronger than the substitution effect, the demand for the good would be positively related to its price. Such a good is called a Giffen good.” |