Read the passage and answer the following questions.
Johnson & Johnson became known for the concept of decentralised management. Instead of operating as one large corporation, it was run as a large number of smaller companies, each focused on a specific medical or product franchise and/or geographic area, with each company generating multiple options for growth. Through decentralisation, it combined the advantages of being big with the speed and focus of smaller firms. Decentralisation enabled each company to stay close to its customers, maintain short lines of communication with customers and employees, and accelerate the development of talent.
Johnson & Johnson has pushed decision making down to its many smaller companies. Even so, decisions that affect the whole group are still taken by its top management. Which of the following explains this?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Decentralisation must be balanced with centralisation in areas of major policy decisions.
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) Decentralisation must be balanced with centralisation in areas of major policy decisions. Correct. | Decentralisation can lead to organisational disintegration if units follow their own guidelines, so it must be balanced with centralisation in major policy decisions; that is why group-wide decisions at Johnson & Johnson stay with top management. |
| Option (2) Decentralisation is a compulsory act, as a manager has limited capacity to perform tasks on his own. Incorrect. | Being needed because of the limited capacity of an individual is true of delegation, not decentralisation, so it does not explain why group-wide decisions stay at the top. |
| Option (3) Decentralisation must be balanced with delegation in areas of routine operational decisions. Incorrect. | Decentralisation is balanced with centralisation, not with delegation, and the area kept at the top is major policy decisions, not routine ones, so this does not explain group decisions staying with top management. |
| Option (4) As an organisation grows in size and complexity, it tends to move towards centralised decision making. Incorrect. | As an organisation grows in size and complexity, it tends to move towards decentralised decision making, not centralised, so growth cannot explain why top management keeps group decisions. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (1) (vi) Better control: “As a conclusion, it must be noted that in spite of its benefits decentralisation should be applied with caution as it can lead to organisational disintegration if the departments start to operate on their own guidelines which may be contrary to the interest of the organisation. Decentralisation must always be balanced with centralisation in areas of major policy decisions.” Wrong options (2), (3) and (4) (vi) Development of personnel: “The reduction in workload by delegation is not just necessary because of limited capacity of an individual but also allows the manager to develop new methods and ways of performing tasks.” Centralisation and Decentralisation: “An organisation can never be completely centralised or decentralised. As it grows in size and complexity , there is a tendency to move towards decentralised decision making.” |