Read the following passage and answer the question.
Mr. Raju is the factory manager of M/s Playing Kids Pvt. Ltd., a toy manufacturing company. In order to ensure unity of command, Mr. Raju appointed just one foreman, Mr. Surya, for the entire production planning, implementation and control of the workmen. However, Surya was not competent enough to supervise both planning and execution. This reduced the quality of work and the efficiency of the workmen. Mr. Raju also expects his subordinates to adapt to a new environment and new working conditions without giving them time to settle down. A good practice in the company is that every piece of equipment, and even every person, has a prescribed place. Mr. Raju gave his subordinate the duty of collecting samples of toys from the office, but the subordinate could not do the task, as only superiors and top executives were allowed to enter the office.
According to Fayol, which of the following is likely to result from what Mr. Raju expects of his subordinates?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Employees may leave the organisation, and recruitment, selection and training cost will be high.
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) Employees may leave the organisation, and recruitment, selection and training cost will be high. Correct. | Expecting subordinates to adapt without time to settle breaks stability of personnel; without reasonable time to show results employees feel insecure and tend to leave, so recruitment, selection and training cost rises. |
| Option (2) Authority is undermined, discipline is in jeopardy, order is disturbed and stability is threatened. Incorrect. | Fayol gives this warning for a breach of unity of command, when an employee gets orders from two superiors; the expectation is about time to settle, not the number of bosses, so this is not the result. |
| Option (3) The work of two divisions will overlap and cause wastage. Incorrect. | Overlapping work of two divisions is what unity of direction forbids; time to settle in a post has nothing to do with divisions, so this is not the result. |
| Option (4) There will be hindrance in activities because things are not in their fixed place. Incorrect. | Hindrance from things out of their fixed place concerns the arrangement of things and people; the expectation concerns time to settle in a post, so this is not the result. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (1) (xii) Stability of Personnel: “They should be given reasonable time to show results. Any adhocism in this regard will create instability/insecurity among employees. They would tend to leave the organisation. Recruitment, selection and training cost will be high.” Wrong options (2) and (3) (iv) Unity of Command: “If an employee gets orders from two superiors at the same time the principle of unity of command is violated. … He felt that if this principle is violated “authority is undermined, discipline is in jeopardy, order disturbed and stability threatened”.” (v) Unity of Direction: “On no account should the working of two divisions overlap.” |