Which of the following were be-shari‘a?
A) Haidaris
B) Malangs
C) Madaris
D) Jogis
E) Qalandars
Choose the correct answer from the given options:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → A, B, C and E
(A) Haidaris — Correct. The Haidaris were one of the radical mystic groups who openly defied the shari'a, so they were called be-shari'a.
(B) Malangs — Correct. The Malangs scorned the khanqah, took to begging and ignored rituals; their defiance of the shari'a made them be-shari'a.
(C) Madaris — Correct. The Madaris were another such radical group, known for their deliberate defiance of the shari'a.
(D) Jogis — Incorrect. Jogis were Hindu yogis. They came to Shaikh Nizamuddin's khanqah as visitors seeking the Shaikh's help; they were not a sufi group defying the shari'a.
(E) Qalandars — Correct. The Qalandars head the list of mystics who took to extreme asceticism and defied the shari'a, so they were be-shari'a.
NCERT (2026-27): “6.2 Outside the khanqah |