Under which condition does the Earning per Share (EPS) of a company rise with an increase in debt?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → When the RoI is higher than the cost of debt
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) When the Return on Investment (RoI) is lower than the cost of debt. Incorrect. | RoI lower than the cost of debt means the funds earn less than the interest paid on debt, so the use of debt reduces the EPS; under this condition EPS falls, not rises, as debt increases. |
| Option (2) When the RoI is equal to the cost of debt. Incorrect. | RoI equal to the cost of debt leaves no difference between RoI and cost of debt, and it is this difference that increases the EPS, so more debt does not make EPS rise here. |
| Option (3) When the RoI is higher than the tax rate. Incorrect. | RoI higher than the tax rate says nothing about the cost of debt, because EPS rises with higher debt only when the cost of debt is lower than the return earned; so this condition does not decide a rise in EPS. |
| Option (4) When the RoI is higher than the cost of debt. Correct. | RoI higher than the cost of debt means the cost of debt is lower than the return earned on funds employed, so with higher use of debt this difference increases the EPS; this is favourable financial leverage. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (4) EBIT-EPS Analysis: “Why is the EPS rising with higher debt? It is because the cost of debt is lower than the return that company is earning on funds employed.” “This is higher than the 10% interest it is paying on debt funds. With higher use of debt, this difference between RoI and cost of debt increases the EPS. This is a situation of favourable financial leverage.” Wrong options (1), (2) and (3) Example II: “In this example, the EPS of the company is falling with increased use of debt. It is because the Company’s rate of return on investment (RoI) is less than the cost of debt.” “In such cases, the use of debt reduces the EPS. This is a situation of unfavourable financial leverage.” |