A company has high fixed operating costs such as building rent, insurance premium and salaries. Which financing choice is better for it?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Lower debt financing, as it must reduce its fixed financing costs
Option (1) Lower debt financing, as it must reduce its fixed financing costs — Correct. Rent, insurance premium and salaries must be paid whatever the sales. With such high fixed operating costs, the company should not add heavy interest as well. So it must reduce fixed financing costs, and lower debt financing is better.
Option (2) Higher debt financing, as fixed operating costs lower business risk — Incorrect. Business risk depends upon fixed operating costs. Higher fixed operating costs raise business risk, and this lowers the capacity to use debt.
Option (3) Higher debt financing, as interest is a tax-deductible expense — Incorrect. Tax deductibility does make debt cheaper. But debt also brings fixed interest, and a company with high fixed operating costs cannot safely take on more fixed charges.
Option (4) Lower debt financing, as it must reduce its fixed operating costs — Incorrect. Rent, insurance and salaries are needs of the business and do not depend on how it is financed. The choice of finance can only cut fixed financing costs, such as interest.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “(e) Fixed Operating Costs: If a business has high fixed operating costs (e.g., building rent, Insurance premium, Salaries, etc.), It must reduce fixed financing costs. Hence, lower debt financing is better. Similarly, if fixed operating cost is less, more of debt financing may be preferred.” “9. Risk Consideration: As discussed earlier, use of debt increases the financial risk of a business. Financial risk refers to a position when a company is unable to meet its fixed financial charges namely interest payment, preference dividend and repayment obligations. Apart from the financial risk, every business has some operating risk (also called business risk). Business risk depends upon fixed operating costs. Higher fixed operating costs result in higher business risk and vice-versa. The total risk depends upon both the business risk and the financial risk. If a firm’s business risk is lower, its capacity to use debt is higher and vice-versa.” |