If there is a positive level of output at which a firm's profit is maximised in the short run, that condition must not hold at that output level.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Price = Short run Average Cost.
A firm maximises its profit at the output where no other output gives more profit. If this output is positive in the short run, three conditions must hold there. Option (3) is not one of them.
Option (1) Price = Short run Marginal Cost. — Must hold (Incorrect). For a price-taking firm, one more unit adds the market price to revenue and SMC to cost. So profit is highest where \( p = SMC \).
Option (2) Short run Marginal Cost is non-decreasing. — Must hold (Incorrect). If SMC were falling at that point, making a little less would raise profit. So that point cannot give the maximum profit.
Option (3) Price = Short run Average Cost. — Need not hold (Correct). Price equals SAC only at the break-even point, where the firm earns just normal profit. At the profit-maximising output, price may be above SAC (extra profit) or below SAC but above AVC (a loss smaller than the fixed cost).
Option (4) Price ≥ Average Variable Cost. — Must hold (Incorrect). If price were below AVC, the firm could not cover even its variable cost. It would lose less by producing nothing, so it produces only if \( p \ge AVC \).
Note: It seems that there is a mistake in the original NTA paper, which prints “that condition must not hold at that output level” when it should read “which condition need not hold at that output level”. Price can equal SAC at the profit-maximising output (at the break-even point), so it is not a condition that must fail there. But it is the only option that is not one of the three conditions, so the question can still be answered.
NCERT (2026-27): “Summary …If there is a positive level of output at which a firm’s profit is maximised in the short run, three conditions must hold at that output level 4.4.4 The Normal Profit and Break-even Point The minimum level of profit that is needed to keep a firm in the existing business is defined as normal profit.… Normal profits are therefore a part of the firm’s total costs.… Profit that a firm earns over and above the normal profit is called the super-normal profit. In the long run, a firm does not produce if it earns anything less than the normal profit. In the short run, however, it may produce even if the profit is less than this level. The point on the supply curve at which a firm earns only normal profit is called the break-even point of the firm. The point of minimum average cost at which the supply curve cuts the LRAC curve (in short run, SAC curve) is therefore the break-even point of a firm.” |