Which of the following is NOT a critique of agricultural subsidies in India?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Farming in India continues to be a risky business.
Some economists want fertiliser subsidies phased out; others want them kept. The critics say subsidies miss their target and cost too much.
Option (1) A substantial amount of fertiliser subsidy also benefits the fertiliser industry. — True. The money does not reach only the farmers it is meant for.
Option (2) The subsidy largely benefits the farmers in the more prosperous regions. — True. Richer regions gain most, not the poor.
Option (3) It is a huge burden on the government’s finances. — True. Subsidies cost the government a great deal.
Option (4) Farming in India continues to be a risky business. — False. This is an argument for subsidies. Supporters say farming is still risky and most farmers are poor.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.3 Agriculture … Further, subsidies are meant to benefit the farmers but a substantial amount of fertiliser subsidy also benefits the fertiliser industry; and among farmers, the subsidy largely benefits the farmers in the more prosperous regions. Therefore, it is argued that there is no case for continuing with fertiliser subsidies; it does not benefit the target group and it is a huge burden on the government’s finances (see also Box 2.6). On the other hand, some believe that the government should continue with agricultural subsidies because farming in India continues to be a risky business. Most farmers are very poor and they will not be able to afford the required inputs without subsidies. Eliminating subsidies will increase the inequality between rich and poor farmers and violate the goal of equity. …” |