Why do scholars hold that the Harappan script was not alphabetical?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → It has too many signs, somewhere between 375 and 400
Option (1) Its longest inscription contains about 26 signs — Not the reason. The longest inscription has about 26 signs, but that is only its length. The length of one inscription does not show what each sign stands for.
Option (2) It was written from right to left on the seals — Not the reason. Writing from right to left is about direction. An alphabet can run in either direction, so this does not decide the matter.
Option (3) It has too many signs, somewhere between 375 and 400 — The reason. In an alphabet, each sign stands for a vowel or a consonant, so only a few dozen signs are needed. The Harappan script has 375 to 400 signs, far too many for an alphabet.
Option (4) Its signs mostly appear beside animal motifs on seals — Not the reason. The animal motif sits beside the writing and may have helped those who could not read. It does not show how the signs work.
NCERT (2026-27): “7.2 An enigmatic script … |