A historian reading Buddhist texts finds that a travelling teacher convinced a rival during a debate held in a kutagarashala. Which consequence of such a success do these texts describe?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → The followers of the rival also became disciples of the teacher.
Option (1) The followers of the rival also became disciples of the teacher. — Correct. Buddhist texts tell us that when a philosopher convinced a rival, the rival's followers also became his disciples. So a sect's support could grow or shrink.
Option (2) The rival was required to leave the region along with his followers. — Incorrect. The loser was not driven out. His followers moved over to the winning teacher.
Option (3) The teacher was invited by the local ruler to perform a sacrifice. — Incorrect. Sacrifices were part of the Vedic tradition run by Brahmana priests. A debate win did not lead to a royal sacrifice.
Option (4) The followers of the rival were admitted to the sangha as bhikkhus. — Incorrect. The sangha was the monastic order of the Buddha's own followers. Here the followers became disciples of the winning teacher; joining a monastic order is a different matter.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.3 Debates and discussions |