Read the following passage and answer the question.
Kulkarni Kitchens
Rohan Kulkarni runs Kulkarni Kitchens, a chain of four takeaway kitchens in Pune. In every kitchen, one cook only kneads the dough, one only runs the tandoor and one only packs the orders. Each of them has been trained for that one task.
The head of each kitchen chooses the weekly specials and hires part-time helpers for the festival rush. The prices on the menu and the opening of any new kitchen, however, are decided by Rohan, who keeps the final say.
The appointment letter of every cook promises one day off each week and lists a fine for coming late to a shift. Last month the kitchens were very busy, but Rohan still gave every cook the weekly day off, and the cooks kept to their shift timings.
Rohan has told the cooks that anyone with a problem must tell the shift supervisor, who takes it to the head of the kitchen, who then takes it to Rohan.
When weekend duty is allotted, Rohan lets the cooks from his home town take their weekends off, while the other cooks have to work every weekend.
Read the following statements:
Assertion (A): The rule Rohan has given the cooks for raising a problem, as described in the passage, follows Fayol’s principle of scalar chain.
Reason (R): According to Fayol, in an emergency, an employee can contact another employee at the same level of authority directly through a gang plank.
In the light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → Both (A) and (R) are true but (R) is NOT the correct explanation of (A).
| Statement | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Assertion (A): The rule Rohan has given the cooks for raising a problem, as described in the passage, follows Fayol’s principle of scalar chain. | True. A cook’s problem goes from the shift supervisor to the head of the kitchen and then to Rohan, level by level, so it follows the formal lines of authority that make the scalar chain. |
| Reason (R): According to Fayol, in an emergency, an employee can contact another employee at the same level of authority directly through a gang plank. | True. |
| Whether R explains A? No. A is about the normal route a problem takes, up each level of the chain. R is about the gang plank, a shorter route used only in an emergency, so it cannot be the reason for the long route. | |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): (ix) Scalar Chain: “The formal lines of authority from highest to lowest ranks are known as scalar chain. … If ‘E’ has to communicate with ‘O’ who is at the same level of authority then she/he has to traverse the route E-D-C-B-A-L-M-N-O. … According to Fayol, this chain should not be violated in the normal course of formal communication. However, if there is an emergency then ‘E’ can directly contact ‘O’ through ‘Gang Plank’ as shown in the diagram.” |