Choose the option that correctly changes the following sentence from the Direct to the Indirect Speech:
Rudra said to Ali, "Why is there so much commotion?"
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Rudra asked Ali why there was so much commotion.
Question (wh-word) in indirect speech:
| Change | Direct | Indirect | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting verb | said to | asked | “Said to” changes to “asked”, with no “to” before the listener: asked Ali. |
| Word order | is there | there is | The question becomes a statement: “is there” becomes “there is”. |
| Tense change | is | was | Past reporting verb, so “is” becomes “was”. The question mark becomes a full stop. |
| Full sentence | Rudra said to Ali, “Why is there so much commotion?” | Rudra asked Ali why there was so much commotion. |
Joining word: the question word why itself joins the clauses. "That" is not used.
Example: He said to me, “Where are you going?” → He asked me where I was going.
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 1: Rudra said to Ali that why is that there so much commotion. — Incorrect.
- "Said to" is kept, and "that why" puts two joining words together.
- The tense is not changed.
Option 2: Rudra asked to Ali why is so much commotion. — Incorrect.
- "asked to Ali": asked takes the listener directly.
- "there" is lost and "is" is not changed to "was".
Option 3: Rudra ordered to Ali why is there so much commotion. — Incorrect. "Ordered" reports a command, not a question. The question order and tense are also unchanged.