The compounds producing Schottky defect, when added to crystals \(AgCl\) are:
A. \(NaCl\)
B. \(CdCl_2\)
C. \(CaCl_2\)
D. \(KCl\)
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → B and C only
When an ionic crystal is grown with a little of a salt whose cation has a higher charge, each such cation takes the place of two host cations: it occupies the site of one and the other site stays empty. The cation vacancies so produced are equal in number to the added divalent ions. This is an impurity defect; because it creates vacant cation sites, it has the same effect as a Schottky-type vacancy, and that is what the question asks for.
In AgCl the host cation is \( \ce{Ag^{+}} \) (charge +1). So only a chloride of a divalent cation can create cation vacancies:
A. NaCl — Does not produce the defect. \( \ce{Na+} \) has the same charge (+1) as \( \ce{Ag+} \); one \( \ce{Na+} \) replaces one \( \ce{Ag+} \), so no vacancy forms.
B. \( \ce{CdCl2} \) — Produces the defect. Each \( \ce{Cd^2+} \) replaces two \( \ce{Ag+} \) ions and leaves one cation site vacant; the solid solution of \( \ce{CdCl2} \) and AgCl is an example.
C. \( \ce{CaCl2} \) — Produces the defect. \( \ce{Ca^2+} \) also carries +2 charge, so each \( \ce{Ca^2+} \) creates one cation vacancy, in the same way as \( \ce{Sr^2+} \) in NaCl.
D. KCl — Does not produce the defect. \( \ce{K+} \) is univalent like \( \ce{Ag+} \); no vacancy is needed to keep the crystal neutral.
Note: This question is from the pre-rationalised NCERT book (2022-23). The topic is not there in the latest NCERT book (2026-27), and it is also out of the CUET 2026 syllabus.
NCERT (Pre-rationalised edition, 2022-23):
Impurity Defects
