Identify the correct statements about the externalities as a limitation of GDP and welfare.
A. GDP as measured does not take into account the external effects of the production of goods.
B. Inverse relationship between negative externality and welfare.
C. No relation between GDP and welfare.
D. Economic activities have both positive and negative externalities.
E. Producers are rewarded with profit for positive externalities.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → A, B, and D only
Externalities are the benefits or harms that a firm or a person causes to others, with no payment made for them. They have no market where they can be bought and sold, so GDP misses them.
A. GDP as measured does not take into account the external effects of the production of goods. — Correct. A refinery that pollutes a river harms the fishermen, and it bears no cost for this. GDP counts the refinery's value added but leaves out this harm.
B. Inverse relationship between negative externality and welfare. — Correct. An inverse relationship means that when one rises, the other falls. More harm to others means less welfare. So GDP overestimates welfare when it ignores negative externalities.
C. No relation between GDP and welfare. — Incorrect. GDP is often taken as a measure of welfare. Externalities make it an imperfect measure, but the two are still related.
D. Economic activities have both positive and negative externalities. — Correct. The polluting refinery is a negative case. Positive externalities also exist, and then GDP underestimates welfare.
E. Producers are rewarded with profit for positive externalities. — Incorrect. By definition, no payment is received for an external benefit. So it brings the producer no profit.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.5 GDP and Welfare … 3. Externalities: Externalities refer to the benefits (or harms) a firm or an individual causes to another for which they are not paid (or penalised). Externalities do not have any market in which they can be bought and sold. For example, let us suppose there is an oil refinery which refines crude petroleum and sells it in the market. The output of the refinery is the amount of oil it refines. We can estimate the value added of the refinery by deducting the value of intermediate goods used by the refinery (crude oil in this case) from the value of its output. The value added of the refinery will be counted as part of the GDP of the economy. But in carrying out the production the refinery may also be polluting the nearby river. This may cause harm to the people who use the water of the river. Hence their well being will fall. Pollution may also kill fish or other organisms of the river on which fish survive. As a result, the fishermen of the river may be losing their livelihood. Such harmful effects that the refinery is inflicting on others, for which it will not bear any cost, are called externalities. In this case, the GDP is not taking into account such negative externalities. Therefore, if we take GDP as a measure of welfare of the economy we shall be overestimating the actual welfare. This was an example of negative externality. There can be cases of positive externalities as well. In such cases, GDP will underestimate the actual welfare of the economy.” |