Read the report carefully and answer the questions based on the report:
| Consumer's Budget | ₹100 |
| Price of Good X | ₹5 per unit |
| Price of Good Y | ₹10 per unit |
In a situation when MRSXY > PX / PY, the consumer would react by.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Increasing the consumption of Good X.
Note: The given answer is as per the official NTA Answer Key. However, the question can have more than one correct answer, i.e. both Option (3) and Option (4), as explained below.
The marginal rate of substitution (\(MRS_{XY}\)) is how much Good Y the consumer is willing to give up for one more unit of Good X. The price ratio \(P_X / P_Y\) is how much Y she has to give up in the market for it. She is at her best point (optimum) only when the two are equal. When \(MRS_{XY} \gt P_X / P_Y\), one more unit of X is worth more to her than it costs.
Option (1) Decreasing the consumption of Good X. — Incorrect. Less X takes her away from the optimum; her MRS would rise even further.
Option (2) Increasing the consumption of Good Y. — Incorrect. On the budget line, more Y means less X, so this is the same wrong move as Option (1).
Option (3) Increasing the consumption of Good X. — Correct. With the given prices, the market asks only half a unit of Y for one more unit of X (\(5/10 = 0.5\)). If she would happily give, say, 2 units of Y, buying it makes her better off. As she buys more X, her MRS falls. She stops when \(MRS_{XY}\) equals \(P_X / P_Y\).
Option (4) Decreasing the consumption of Good Y. — Should also be correct, though not the answer given by NTA. On the budget line, she can pay for more X only by buying less Y. More X and less Y are two halves of one move.
Advice for the exam: When more than one option is correct, mark the one that answers the question most completely as per the NCERT book, here Option (3), which is about Good X, because \(MRS_{XY}\) measures what one more unit of X is worth to her. If NTA’s provisional answer key marks a different option, challenge it during the answer-key challenge window, giving proper reasoning. NTA does revise its key when a challenge is well justified, so a sound challenge can raise your marks.
NCERT (2026-27): “Price Ratio and the Slope of the Budget Line Think of any point on the budget line. Such a point represents a bundle which costs the consumer her entire budget. Now suppose the consumer wants to have one more banana. She can do it only if she gives up some amount of the other good.… …Recall from our earlier discussion that the slope of the indifference curve is the rate at which the consumer is willing to substitute one good for the other. The slope of the budget line is the rate at which the consumer is able to substitute one good for the other in the market. At the optimum, the two rates should be the same. To see why, consider a point where this is not so. Suppose the MRS at such a point is 2 and suppose the two goods have the same price. At this point, the consumer is willing to give up 2 mangoes if she is given an extra banana. But in the market, she can buy an extra banana if she gives up just 1 mango. Therefore, if she buys an extra banana, she can have more of both the goods compared to the bundle represented by the point, and hence, move to a preferred bundle. Thus, a point at which the MRS is greater, the price ratio cannot be the optimum.…” |