A Buddhist text describes two teachers, each with his own band of followers, who met while travelling from place to place in the Ganga valley. Before a crowd of laypersons, they argued for several days about the validity of their philosophy and the way they understood the world. At the end of the debate, one teacher admitted that his rival's view was the correct one.
Based on such debates of the mid-first millennium BCE, what usually followed from this outcome?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → The followers of the convinced teacher became disciples of the winning teacher.
Option (1) The followers of the convinced teacher became disciples of the winning teacher. — Correct. When a philosopher convinced a rival, the followers of the rival also became his disciples. This is how support for a sect grew or shrank.
Option (2) The convinced teacher joined the winner, while his followers kept to their old sect. — Incorrect. The followers did not stay behind. They went over with their teacher and became disciples of the winner.
Option (3) The convinced teacher's followers were free to choose any of the 64 sects. — Incorrect. The 64 sects show how many schools of thought existed. The followers did not pick freely among them; they joined the winning teacher.
Option (4) The two teachers merged their followers into one new sect under joint leadership. — Incorrect. No joint sect was formed. The winner's sect grew, and the loser's sect lost its followers.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.3 Debates and discussions |