Meera, a student from Pune, visits a monastery in Ladakh with her teacher. On the shelves she sees books in Pali and in Chinese. The teacher tells her that the Buddhist tradition did not begin as a library. It grew among people who gathered to hear the teacher and talked among themselves about what they had heard. Over the centuries it moved into new lands, monks and lay followers there composed further works, and visitors came to India from far away. Meera notes down a few questions to check later in her History textbook.
A guide at the monastery makes two claims to Meera:
a- The Buddha's speeches were written down during his lifetime by his close disciples.
b- His teachings were compiled by his disciples at a council of elders or senior monks at Sarnath.
Which of the claims is/are correct?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Neither of the claims is correct.
Option (1) Claim a alone is correct. — Incorrect. Claim a is false. The Buddha taught orally, and none of his speeches were written down during his lifetime.
Option (2) Claim b alone is correct. — Incorrect. Claim b is false. His disciples compiled the teachings after his death at a council of senior monks at Vesali (Vaishali in Bihar), and Sarnath was where he gave his first sermon.
Option (3) Both claims are correct. — Incorrect. Both claims fail: the speeches were never written in his lifetime, and the council met at Vesali.
Option (4) Neither of the claims is correct. — Correct. Neither claim holds. The teaching was oral while the Buddha lived, and the compiling council met at Vesali.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.3 Debates and discussions … |