When does the earnings per share (EPS) rise with higher debt?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → When the rate of return on investment is higher than the rate of interest.
Option (1) When the rate of return on investment is higher than the rate of interest. — Correct. Debt costs a fixed rate of interest. If the firm earns a higher return on investment than this rate, the extra return on the borrowed money goes to the equity shareholders. So more debt raises the EPS. This is favourable financial leverage.
Option (2) When the rate of return on investment is lower than the rate of interest. — Incorrect. Then the borrowed money earns less than its interest. The shortfall comes out of the equity profit, so the EPS falls. This is unfavourable financial leverage.
Option (3) When the rate of return on investment is equal to the rate of interest. — Incorrect. The borrowed money then earns only enough to pay its own interest. Nothing extra is left for the equity shareholders, so more debt does not raise the EPS.
Option (4) When the tax rate is higher than the rate of interest. — Incorrect. Interest is a deductible expense, so a higher tax rate makes debt cheaper. But the tax rate and the interest rate measure different things. The EPS rises with debt only when the RoI is higher than the cost of debt.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “EBIT-EPS Analysis … The impact of financial leverage on the profitability of a business can be seen through EBIT-EPS (Earning before Interest and Taxes-Earning per Share) analysis as in the following example. Three situations are considered. There is no debt in situation-I i.e. (unlevered business). Debt of Rs. 10 lakh and 20 lakh are assumed in situations-II and III, respectively. All debt is at 10% p.a. The company earns Rs. 0.93 per share if it is unlevered. With debt of Rs. 10 lakh its EPS is Rs. 1.05. With a still higher debt of Rs. 20 lakh, its, EPS rises to Rs. 1.40. Why is the EPS rising with higher debt? It is because the cost of debt is lower than the return that company is earning on funds employed. The company is earning a Return on Investment (RoI). …” “4. Return on Investment (RoI): If the RoI of the company is higher, it can choose to use trading on equity to increase its EPS, i.e., its ability to use debt is greater. We have already observed in Example I that a firm can use more debt to increase its EPS. However, in Example II, use of higher debt is reducing the EPS. It is because the firm is earning an RoI of only 6.67% which lower than its cost of debt. In example I the RoI is 13.33%, and trading on equity is profitable. It shows that, RoI is an important determinant of the company’s ability to use Trading on equity and thus the capital structure.” |