"According to a management expert, "even a small production activity like loading pigs of iron into boxcars can be scientifically planned and managed. This can result in tremendous saving of human energy as well as wastage of time and materials." Identify the principle of scientific management advocated in the aforesaid statement.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Science, not rule of thumb
Option (1) Cooperation, not individualism — Incorrect. This principle asks management and workers to work together and not compete with each other. The statement is not about relations between the two.
Option (2) Harmony, not discord — Incorrect. This principle asks for complete harmony between management and workers, through a change in their thinking (mental revolution). The statement is about the method of doing a job.
Option (3) Science, not rule of thumb — Correct. Taylor believed that there is one best method for every job. This method is found through study and analysis. It should replace the rule of thumb, that is, each manager’s own guesswork. Taylor said that even loading pigs of iron into boxcars can be scientifically planned and managed. This saves human energy, time and materials.
Option (4) Development of each and every person to his or her greatest efficiency and prosperity — Incorrect. This principle is about choosing and training workers scientifically, so that each reaches his best efficiency. The statement is about planning the work, not about training the worker.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “Science not Rule of Thumb: Taylor pioneered the introduction of the method of scientific inquiry into the domain of management practice. We have already referred to the limitations of the rule of thumb approach of management. As different managers would follow their indigenous rules of thumb, it is but a statement of the obvious that all would not be equally effective. Taylor believed that there was only one best method to maximise efficiency. This method can be developed through study and analysis. The method so developed should substitute ‘Rule of Thumb’ throughout the organisation. Scientific method involved investigation of traditional methods through work-study, unifying the best practices and developing a standard method, which would be followed throughout the organisation. According to Taylor, even a small production activity like loading pigs of iron into boxcars can be scientifically planned and managed. This can result in tremendous saving of human energy as well as wastage of time and materials. The more sophisticated the processes, greater would be the savings.” |