Sita and Geeta are two close friends and both are graduate working women. Sita is an economics graduate and doing research in economics while Geeta is a customer relation manager in a multinational company. On 1st January, 2023 both the friends decide to go out for a dinner to celebrate new year. Geeta is fond of Ice-Cream (Orange bar) and has decided to buy it from a street vendor at ₹10/unit after discount. She has also offered it to Sita but Sita refused as she was having a throat infection.
Geeta has requested Sita to apply economics principles and to tell her when she should stop consuming more ice-cream. On consuming the 3rd unit of Ice-cream, Geeta has obtained additional satisfaction of 18 utils while the marginal utility of a rupee is 2 utils.
Which of the following is not the assumption of Utility Approach?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Consumer is having monotonic Preferences.
The utility approach, or cardinal utility analysis, assumes that utility can be measured in numbers. Monotonic preferences belong to the other approach, the indifference curve (ordinal) analysis.
Option (1) Price of the commodity remains constant. — An assumption (Incorrect). The approach studies how many units a consumer buys at a given price. So the price is taken as fixed while she decides.
Option (2) Law of diminishing marginal utility exists — An assumption (Incorrect). Marginal utility (MU) is the extra utility from one more unit. The approach assumes that each successive unit gives lower marginal utility. This is what makes the demand curve slope downward.
Option (3) Utility is expressed in terms of utils. — An assumption (Incorrect). The approach puts a number on utility, for example 50 units of utility from a shirt. These units of utility are called utils.
Option (4) Consumer is having monotonic Preferences. — Not an assumption of this approach (Correct). Preferences are monotonic when the consumer prefers a bundle with more of at least one good and no less of the other. The idea is used to rank bundles in ordinal analysis, where utility is not measured in numbers.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.1.1 Cardinal Utility Analysis Cardinal utility analysis assumes that level of utility can be expressed in numbers. For example, we can measure the utility derived from a shirt and say, this shirt gives me 50 units of utility. Before discussing further, it will be useful to have a look at two important measures of utility.… Derivation of Demand Curve in the Case of a Single Commodity (Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility) … The law of diminishing marginal utility states that each successive unit of a commodity provides lower marginal utility. Therefore the individual will not be willing to pay as much for each additional unit and this results in a downward sloping demand curve.… 2.1.2 Ordinal Utility Analysis Cardinal utility analysis is simple to understand, but suffers from a major drawback in the form of quantification of utility in numbers. In real life, we never express utility in the form of numbers. At the most, we can rank various alternative combinations in terms of having more or less utility. In other words, the consumer does not measure utility in numbers, though she often ranks various consumption bundles. This forms the starting point of this topic – Ordinal Utility Analysis.… Monotonic Preferences Consumer’s preferences are assumed to be such that between any two bundles (x1, x2) and (y1, y2), if (x1, x2) has more of at least one of the goods and no less of the other good compared to (y1, y2), then the consumer prefers (x1, x2) to (y1, y2). Preferences of this kind are called monotonic preferences.…” |